Updated, for all time:
Readers are nearly 100% for judging this one. It was a fake. And the site with a really stupid name (hellohomo??) admits that it was faux.
Howard Stern Hoaxed! Beyoncé "Outtakes" Are Fake, Creator Admits [E! Online]
Wow, that may be the last time CDM links to E!
Lesson learned: yes, the Internet has the power to spread rumors at new speeds. It can also debunk them even faster. That’s something to pass along to the “get off my lawn!” crowd.
Okay, sound engineers and audiophile experts out there: it’s time to play “is this YouTube video real?” (And, heck, even if it’s not, it’s oddly hilarious.)
A recent episode of Howard Stern’s Sirius radio show claimed to expose a “leaked” feed of the raw vocals for Beyonce Knowles as she sang live on the Today Show. I could try to describe just what they sound like, but it’s really best to hear for yourself.
So, what’s the deal? You can hear the in-tune vocals in the background, as though they actually are bleeding into the mic. Does Beyonce have access to some super-secret, military grade version of Auto-Tune? Is the difference between her processed voice and her actual voice as comically radical as depicted in the ‘N Sync episode of The Simpsons?
I mean, I know – YouTube? Blogs? Howard Stern? The Internet? How much more credibility could you possibly ask for?
I’ll let you be the judge. For the record, the Today Show audience actually heard this.
Found via the brilliantly-domained Yes But No But Yes and Matt Ganucheau. YBNBY or whatever you want to call it describes the singing talentes here as “a parrot being sawed in half.” Hatebeak, an actual parrot trying to sound as though he’s being sawed in half and unofficial mascot of CDM, I’m sure you’re jealous.
Previously: the Great Van Halen Detuned Keyboard Incident.
Oh yeah, and you may want to download this video before someone has it removed.
And yes, hey, if it’s just a fake, it goes nicely with the "shreds" video meme. So bring it on.
Updated: Consensus is that it’s a beautifully-executed fake. (I’m inclined to agree – sorry, Mr. Stern.) And to think, we thought all this time the advantage of tools like Melodyne and Auto-Tune would be taking out-of-tune things and making them in-tune – ignoring the expressive potential of doing the reverse.
Britney, meanwhile? That’s another story.
Now, what I’m curious about:
Who faked this?
How did they do it?
Speculation?